Opinion

Will global warming change Native American religious practices?

What does the shrinking of the Colorado River mean for Native American religions? Ken Lund, CC BY-SA

(The Conversation) The Colorado River, one of the longest rivers in the United States, is gradually shrinking. This is partly a result of overuse by municipalities and seasonal drought. The other reason is global warming.

The decline in the river reservoir will have serious implications for large U.S. cities, such as Los Angeles, that depend on the Colorado River as their water source. In addition, this will also have an impact on the Native American tribes who view the Colorado River as sacred to their religions.

As Ka-Voka Jackson, a member of the Hualapai tribe and a graduate student working to address climate change on the Colorado River and restoring native plant species along its banks, stated,

“The Colorado River is so sacred not just to my tribe, but to so many others.”

As a scholar of Native American religions and the environment, I understand how indigenous people’s religions and sacred places are closely tied to their landscape. For the past 100 years, indigenous peoples have been forced to adapt to changes in their environments and modify their religious rituals in the United States. The U.S. government made certain Native American religious practices illegal in the 19th and early 20th century. Although these policies have since been rescinded, they led to changes in many indigenous practices.

Global warming, however, is different. The question is whether indigenous people will be able to adapt their beliefs all over again due to the impact of global warming on the natural world.

Adapting to change

The Blackfeet tribe in Montana brought changes in their relationship with the natural world as a result of the policies of the U.S. government from the 1880s to the 1930s.

For example, the Blackfeet purposefully moved religious ceremonies from one time on their liturgical calendar to completely different times to avoid the U.S. government penalizing native people for dancing or participating in religious ceremonies.

The Blackfeet moved their annual O’kan, or sundance festival, from late summer (usually held at the end of August) to the Fourth of July celebration. They avoided U.S. government punishment by masking their ceremonies within state-sanctioned public events.

Policies related to the mining of natural resources and damming of rivers on indigenous lands have also led to changes in Native Americans’ religious practices.

Historian David R. M. Beck interviewed elders and researched how the Menominee tribe in Wisconsin adapted to the loss of their sacred fish, the sturgeon, after a paper mill built a dam across the Wolf River.

Lake sturgeon on Bad River in Wisconsin.
USFWSmidwest, CC BY

The sturgeon disappeared after the dam was built in 1892, because they could no longer swim upstream to spawn. For over 100 years, the Menominee tribal members continued to pray and conduct their annual “returning of the sturgeon” ceremony in the spring – even though there were no more sturgeon in the river. The Menominee ultimately won the right to return the sturgeon to the Wolf River in 1992 and the tribe revitalized the full ceremony and celebration of their sacred fish.

In all these situations, Native American tribes learned to adapt to the challenges placed before them, modify their religious practice and embrace a different relationship with the natural world.

Global warming and religion

When it comes to global climate change, it affects everyone, not just specific groups in specific places. But for many indigenous peoples, natural resources are closely linked to religious beliefs and practices.

Historically, indigenous peoples used the natural seasonal cycles of weather, plants and animals as part of their liturgical or religious calendar. The Blackfeet held their annual “beaver bundle ceremony” in the early spring as ice melted off rivers and beavers returned to the open waters. In Blackfeet mythology, a beaver served as a deity who taught humans how to cultivate tobacco, which the tribe used for important religious ceremonies and as a peace offering to their enemies.

What would the movement of beavers mean?
Bryn Davies, CC BY-NC-ND

There are signs, though, that beavers are now moving north due to global warming. Biologists are currently studying both beavers and the birch and alder shrubs
that beavers eat, as both move north into new regions. Scientists worry that as a keystone species, the movement of beavers will change the northern ecosystems as they cut off waterways and build beaver dams. And shrubs will change the local waterways that they grow by. This will affect local animal species.

What will happen when there are no more beaver in Blackfeet territory? Will their religious traditions adapt similar to the Menominee when they faced the loss of their sacred sturgeon?

Religion and resiliency

From the arctic tundra to the American desert southwest, and places worldwide, indigenous peoples will be facing the impact of global climate change.

Regarding the shrinking of the Colorado River, researchers Brad Udall and Jonathan Overpeck have concluded that, “Failing to act on climate change means accepting the very high risk that the Colorado River basin will continue to dry up into the future.”

If this river faces a drier future, it will likely affect the Mojave, a people indigenous to the Colorado River basin, who believe the river was created by their ancient deity Mastamho as part of their sacred landscape.

As the G-20 convenes in Germany this week to discuss global issues including climate change, indigenous scholars, such as myself, are wondering what the future holds for indigenous peoples, their environments and their religions.

The ConversationIndigenous communities can be resilient and adapt their internal religious beliefs to outside challenges, as Native American tribes from the turn of the 20th century have proven. Climate change presents yet another challenge.

(Rosalyn R. LaPier is research associate of Women’s Studies, Environmental Studies and Native American Religion, Harvard Divinity School, Harvard University. This article was originally published on The Conversation)

About the author

The Conversation

The Conversation is an independent, nonprofit source of expert news and views, from the academic and research community, written for the public.

4 Comments

Click here to post a comment

  • In time the term “indigenous” will come to have no intrinsic meaning. The Global Village is shrinking rapidly in a practical sense apart from global warming. Should humanity survive all the potential threats to our existence, which are largely a function of our inability to get along, share resources, and properly steward the planet, any people’s tie to a particular region will become nothing more than a matter of sentiment, and people are prone to mass migration when the situation requires it. The situation in North America is not unique in human history, it is only of moment now because it is Now. This will be of no comfort to Native Americans, but it is an unhappy fact for them that in the future most of their traditions religious or otherwise will be a mere footnote of history in the greater scheme of things. I do not say this with malice or prejudicial intent, but eventually it seems likely that all they will have are their memories. That will be true for all of us when it is said and done. There is every historical precedent to support this view.

  • How very condescending. No comment on how Christians led the charge to make their language, culture and religion a footnote before its time?

  • what kind of occult religion, news article is this? that claims you can have, global warming and word worlds, world pandemics, without angering ELOHEEM.when we, are all here in this finite limited seven day physical theocracy.
    and all i, hear you defending are other g-ds and subtle talking critter g-ds. when the only thing, being the enemy of ELOHEEM shall give to you is increasing hell and death.
    ELOHEEM And THEIR Son, did not promise any of THEIR enemies a thorn-less rose garden.
    THEY, commanded what you all physically did the last time. with all of your, mental worship going to other idols/g-ds/subtle talking critters. with your, mental free will screwing up the same again this time expecting different physical commanded results.
    mentally worshiping other g-ds and subtle talking creatures, is what destroys nations, peoples, and yourselves. you can’t blame anyone else as long as you the fault too.

  • My comment was framed from the perspective of historic human trends, not a comment on the venal and avaricious character of many of those who professed Christianity who violated biblical precepts of justice in order to obtain Lebensraum. I suppose however, that my declaration that Christianity is superior to Nativist Religious Practices would appear condescending to those who are not Christians. But that too has a historical basis across many cultures and I am unable to counteract it by any other means than winning skeptics to the faith so that they may understand that it is so. Those who reject that premise are certainly free to do so without any rancor from me.

ADVERTISEMENTs